Edit: There seems to be some confusion over the fact I used the term ‘art vs craft debate’ at the start of this post. The craft revolution blog, and this post, is not about the art vs craft debate/discussion, and I am sorry if this post reads that way. I have written another post hopefully to clarify my intention.
I have written before about the art v craft debate. (If you can be bothered – click on the craft category and check out the volumes I wrote before anyone was reading my blog). I have stated that I think the term craft should be embraced, as other pejorative terms have been embraced. I tried to coin a new label – crartist for the craft artist so we can have crartistic licence (it hasn’t caught on. Grin).
Sometimes I wonder if some of those out there who call themselves artists do so, not so much to embrace the term artist, but to distance themselves from the term craft. Craft can have such negative low brow connotations. The much maligned toilet roll covers, tissue box covers, crap-booking (as our neighbour calls it when his scrapbooking loving wife isn’t around). The dumbing down of craft books (SharonB wrote about this here )– the fact I can’t go into McBookshop Borders and find an interesting embroidery book among the shelves jam packed with quick and easy, boring and unsatisfying craft projects. Of course I don’t really think labels matter – I don’t care if you call yourself an artist, a craftsperson, a maker, or a poo shaped yam, but I do think it is a shame to malign all craft because some aspects of it don’t appeal.
I was searching for something last night and stumbled across an exhibition being held at QUT (Queensland University of Technology) called Craft Revolution, running until 13 July. This is what they say:
Craft Revolution explores the idea that craft is radical and revolutionary, through an exhibition and online discussion.
Craft Revolution: The Exhibition…
Rejecting the dominant culture of consumption and the loss of community, craft is a means of creation and engagement that is slow, purposeful and often cooperative. It is this rejection of the dominant consumptive culture and the return to historic or traditional practices that makes craft revolutionary.
Craft Revolution is a celebration of craft in all its naïve and sophisticated forms. The exhibition intends to reclaim the word craft and reject the negative associations this term has acquired. Essentially, Craft Revolution recognises the importance of a practice that has been a part of all cultures for thousands of years and rejoices in the impact craft has had and continues to have on the world.
And because it is really annoying to be told about something that you can’t visit because you don’t happen to live in Brisbane (except for me and Marg of course) you’ll have to visit the blog called craft revolution. Posting schedule: Monday – ‘I (heart) craft!’ with craft lovers talking about their affiliation with this practice. Wednesdays – ‘Exploring the revolution’ as craft writers and theorists discuss their opinion on the importance and future of craft. Fridays – craft makers telling their personal stories of creation, or a short history of some of the different craft guilds in QLD.
There are a few interesting posts there already –it’s not all textile related of course. There is an interesting article called ‘The real deal’. The author suggests that we get over ourselves (my words not hers) – accept the fact that there are some negative association with the terms craft, embrace all aspects of craft (even the kitschy toilet roll covers) and get on with it. Her conclusion:
The real revolution of craft will begin if we can get over all of this, learn to love craft, and accept the many facets of craft culture. Then we can begin to deal with a real issue, like the fact that glass and ceramics schools are closing left, right and centre, and soon there will be nothing left to debate about.
Don’t take my word for it – do go and check it out.
Some kitschy craft of my own

Moo and I have been having fun with the embellisher. She can sit on my lap and move the stuff around (we have only broken one needle doing this so far). We are playing and making Moo inspired and directed things. This is our seascape- fancy yarn and acrylic felt.
Lunch from the garden


I picked lunch from the garden yesterday: silver beet, spinach, spring onion, lettuce, corn, oranges, corn, beetroot, eggs, as well as cucumber, lemon, coriander and mint (not shown) I forgot to pick those and had to go back out. I made frittata with the eggs, silver beet, onions and zucchini. The bright pink stuff is my take on Stephanie Alexanders raw beetroot and yoghurt salad. We had to buy in the tomatoes and olives (the tomatoes failed– too cold and the olive trees aren’t bearing fruit yet).
Recipe: beetroot and yoghurt salad – my version
Grated raw beetroot, lemon juice, mint, coriander, Greek yoghurt, sour cream, pepper. Mix. This is yummy and the kids liked it.



I think the “s” is the way to differentiate between the crafting process that requires skill, patience, design sense, etc. and the one that’s “quick and easy” (ie, “craft” as opposed to “crafts”.)
How about the Rosen Group’s Buyer’s Market for American Craft (http://www.americancraft.com/BMAC/aboutus.html) and the Smithsonian Craft Show (http://smithsoniancraftshow.org/)? No “s”es there!
Comment by Jeannette — June 15, 2008 @ 11:05 am
If I could grow veges like that then maybe I would like gardening–but don’t hold your breath.
Comment by Doreen Grey — June 15, 2008 @ 11:52 am
Thanks for the interesting link; all I can say is “amen” to anything that celebrates the handmade over the mass produced, imported, and disposable. Several years ago I vowed never to buy another Chinese Christmas ornament, and it hasn’t been hard. (Of course, I already have some…)
Your daughter will have wonderful memories of running the embellisher with you!
Comment by Kay — June 15, 2008 @ 9:34 pm
[...] under Craft | Tags: Art, Craft | Paula over on The Beauty of life has written a very interesting post about the art/craft debate. Like me Paula does not see the term craft as a derogatory tag but many do and it is since the [...]
Pingback by A difference between debate and discussion « In a Minute Ago — June 16, 2008 @ 7:35 am
Hey Paula, I stopped by to thank you for making me laugh again! So glad you liked Rowan and Phoebe.
I was just off to bed when I thought I’d have a visit with you and I’ve been here for ages. So , it’s your fault if I’m even more useless tomorrow.
About ‘craft’, well we’re always chuntering on about it having a bad name, likewise mention ‘textiles’ and most galleries don’t want to know, the answer, I don’t know. But I am sure that as artists, we have to work with integrity and value our endeavours. Ooh, this is a bit deep for me at this time of night. Sleep well.
Comment by annette emms — June 16, 2008 @ 8:11 am
Lately I’m thinking that art and craft are just in different spots on the same creative continuum. And oddly, I too have been searching for a word that combines both concepts, unsuccessfully so far.
I’ve written about the dumbing-down too, and I still maintain that it isn’t just craft books — it’s evident in every category where the marketers decide that women are the target audience. They make everything about shopping, and assume we want things to be cute and easy and not too challenging for our wee little brains, written in a “sassy” style full of exclamation points and . . . oh, my, I could go on and on. But I won’t. I’ll just say I’m grateful for the many people who seem interested in a lively, fun and yes, intelligent discussion of artandcraft. Thanks Paula.
Comment by Lainie — June 16, 2008 @ 10:44 am
i’ve had too much saki, so i will read this later…..
Comment by jude — June 16, 2008 @ 11:04 am
now that everyone calls him/herself an artist i’m more interested in crafts and its social and political implications
here’s a good link on the topic.
http://redefiningcraft.dennisstevens.net/
and he also has an impeccable dissertation here http://www.redefiningcraft.com/wp-content/coda2006/player.html
neki desu
Comment by neki rivera — June 16, 2008 @ 6:17 pm
Hi Paula, A very interesting topic, I do think that a very good word to use would be that of Artisan. It covers it all really. The last time I heard this term it was in a gardening programme that we have here in the UK. It was mentioned quite a lot in relation to making a cottage garden. I like the term really because it encompasses it all. There is a definition on Wikipedia which is good to look at, tell me what you think if you get chance. Tricia
Comment by Tricia Cook — June 16, 2008 @ 8:38 pm
ok now i am sober and i have read it and i will post something about this a bit later. as always, thank you for your down to earth approach….
Comment by jude — June 17, 2008 @ 3:17 am
Wonderful post Paula. I agree with devalue and dumb down craft so often. I wonder what the purpose is as well. Love your little fish piece.
Comment by Linda — June 17, 2008 @ 5:19 am
Trust me to be late at the gate..I’m going to keep tabs on the blog you mentioned Paula-looks interesting and I’m with Tricia on the Artisan idea-it seems to encompass my Jack of all Trades approach.
The little embellisher pieces will be priceless in a few years and yes, Moo will remember making them with love. As she will gathering produce from your garden.
Comment by threadspider — June 18, 2008 @ 12:59 am
I have been reading your blogs with great interest as I am writing my dissertation over the summer holidays and the subject is….art versus craft with a particular reference to stained glass/architectural glass art.
I find the comments from others fascinating, it’s wonderful (and helpful) to hear so many different viewpoints on the same subject.
Thank you to everyone
(BTW the lunch looks wonderful, all those beautiful fresh, natural colours; a craft in itself.)
Amanda
Comment by Amanda Wheaton — June 19, 2008 @ 3:06 am
I love the garden-to-the-table photo! Most inspiring…
I can only imagine how wonderful it would be to go out and pick a few oranges.
The beet root salad looks great; we will try that when our beets get big enough.
I’ve never understood the art/craft divide…I guess I am more interested in the personal experience of the creator. Does the “making” bring joy and meaning, fulfillment and wonder? That’s what matters to me….but if I had to choose a label, “artisan” wold be it. Hopefully!
Comment by Allison Aller — June 21, 2008 @ 10:43 pm