Despite my using the phrase ‘art v craft debate’ yesterday, my post was not intended to be another rehash of that debate, or discussion, if you’d prefer. In fact in earlier posts about this topic I have stated that I think it is a non-issue. I think both are equally valid, equally important; I wasn’t implying that the topic was black and white – of course there are shades of grey, and I think most (all?) would acknowledge that. As I pointed out I don’t care what we call ourselves or label what we do, or make.
I think by focussing attention on one, admittedly ill-considered (and as far as I am concerned the least important), phrase in my post, the point of the post may have been missed. My point was not that art and craft are ‘diametrically opposed’ or even that the point is worth arguing about (falsely or otherwise). Sharonb’s statement that ‘It is possible to define, discuss and tease out ideas without framing the discussion in term of a debate and if done so could lead somewhere provided it is a genuine discussion instead if setting this idea against that idea’, is of course true. It was not however, my intention to continue the debate, discussion or otherwise on this topic. My point was to suggest that the term craft is often devalued. The blog and discussion on craft revolution is not a debate, or even a discussion, about art v craft, and it would be a shame for anybody to infer that, simply because I thoughtlessly used that term in my post.
The discussion on craft revolution is about valuing craft, for craft’s sake, in all its forms – crocheted toilet roll covers to exquisite works of art.



Isn’t it all art anyway?
smiles,
alicia in Hawaii
Comment by alicia in Hawaii — June 16, 2008 @ 5:40 pm
Oh I am so glad you posted this, Paula, as I was beginning to think I had misinterpreted your post yesterday; but it seems I hadn’t. I get so tired of the art v craft ridiculousness – what on earth does it matter what word is used! The thing that annoys me most about such debates or discussions is that it appears to say some work is less valuable than other work, and that is something I just do not believe. The work of someone who says she does “craft work” is just as valuable as someone who insists she is an artist. The whole “art” is better than “craft” thing smacks of snobbery to me.
Art is craft. Craft is art. An artisan is skilled at his craft. A craftsman is skilled at his art. The art of [fill in the blank] is just the same as practicing the craft of [fill in the blank].
BTW – I loved the sound of the beetroot and yoghurt salad so I tried it for dinner last night. Fabulous – thank you for the idea.
Jocelyn
Comment by Jocelyn — June 17, 2008 @ 7:04 am
Gosh Paula – I have just dropped you an email but I did not mean to focus the disucssion in that way. I meant to point out that you were talking about revaluing craft in a world that has been dominated by the art craft debate
Comment by sharonb — June 17, 2008 @ 12:55 pm
Hi, Paula, after your comment about Just stitch, and your pomegranate and forbidden fruit, I have commanded Just stitch. It was difficult because, they are no more book: too many success!!; But I have…………….Waouh!!!Superb. I am so happy and full of dreams. thanks for your recommandation and useful blog!
Comment by anne — June 18, 2008 @ 10:41 pm